The pricetag includes both the purchase price and long-term sustainment costs for the jets. "Total ownership" of the program had previously been estimated at $16 to $18 billion.
The Liberals said the budget officer's estimate is a "far cry from the bogus" figures put forward by the government and that Page's report shows the Conservatives "misled" Canadians on the cost of the F-35 deal. "This is an unconscionable amount of money," Dominic LeBlanc, the Liberals' defence critic, said at a news conference following the release of the report.
Parliamentary budget officer Kevin Page, who has cast doubt before on the government's accounting practices, was asked by the Liberal Opposition to look at the F-35 deal with U.S. defence giant Lockheed Martin.
Previous reports by Page have questioned the government's deficit projections and its plan to cut the size and cost of the federal bureaucracy.
Thursday's report again puts him at odds with the Conservatives and gives weight to opposition party arguments that the purchase of the jets would cost more than the government has been saying. To arrive at his estimate of $29.3 billion, Page said he used a "top-down" model that considered historical trends on the cost of aircraft and key cost drivers. Page estimates the acquisition cost for the fleet at $9.7 billion and the ongoing sustainment cost for it at $19.6 billion. The sustainment cost breaks down as follows:
- initial logistics set-up cost: $1.7 billion;
- operating and support cost: $14 billion;
- overhaul and upgrade cost: $3.9 billion.
"DND confirmed that such an analysis has not yet been undertaken," the report says.
Defence Minister Peter MacKay reacted quickly to Page's report.
A spokesman for the minister said national defence experts "stand by their cost projections."
Jay Paxton said the government has committed $9 billion to acquire the planes and $250 to $300 million annually over a 20-year period to support the planes.
"This report is intended as a preliminary set of data for discussion. The F-35 is the only jet that can meet the needs of the Air Force, as noted by Mr. Page. Simply put, this is the best plane for the best price and we are confident in our acquisition," Paxton said.
The Conservatives say the planes are needed to replace Canada's aging CF-18s. The life cycle of that fleet is to end around 2017.
Liberal MP Marc Garneau said Page's report justifies the position taken by his party to cancel the deal and hold an open bid for new planes.
"This report makes it clearer than ever that the Liberal Party of Canada is making the right choice to cancel this untendered purchase process," he said.
Page was asked to weigh in on whether a competitive bid would have saved money compared to the cost of the sole-sourced deal, but Thursday's report doesn't include an opinion. Page says there is insufficient data for him to render an opinion on which procurement method would be best.
Possible election issue
The timing of Page's report could prove to be critical because the Conservatives are weeks away from a possible defeat in the House of Commons. The budget is due to be presented on March 22 and if it doesn't pass, an election could follow. The government may also fall if a non-confidence motion is presented by the Liberal Opposition.
An F-35 Joint Strike Fighter is seen in an Ottawa hangar before the government's official announcement of a deal to buy the aircraft on July 16, 2010. Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press The Liberals have been using the F-35 deal as a line of attack against Harper.The Liberals say an open competition should have been held before the government decided to proceed with Lockheed Martin's jets. They are being purchased through the Joint Strike Fighter program, a multinational partnership that will see Lockheed Martin produce thousands of jets.
The government says it would be irresponsible to cancel the purchase of the jets, a plan developed with Canada's allies, and Defence Minister Peter MacKay insists the cost of the jets is firm.
MacKay said cancelling the deal would "endanger the lives of Canadian pilots" and "endanger the sovereignty of this country."
The government also says the deal would bring millions of dollars in benefits to the Canadian aerospace industry through contracts.
MacKay defended the $9-billion figure in the House of Commons Wednesday.
"We have committed $9 billion for the acquisition of 65 aircraft. These are the same aircraft that the party opposite committed to back in 1997," MacKay said, in reference to Liberal government's involvement in an earlier phase of the fighter jet program.
"This $9 billion is committed not only for the cost of the 65 aircraft, but also the associated weapons system, supporting infrastructure, initial spares, training simulators, contingency funds and project operating costs," MacKay said.
Page warns that the total pricetag for the F-35s is subject to change due to a number of factors including: possible modifications to the technical specifications of the aircraft, any reductions in the number of planes countries participating in the Joint Strike Fighter program end up purchasing and the "circumstances prevailing" when the planes are due for a mid-life overhaul.
He also points out that his analysis of the F-35 program is based largely on historical data and that the possibility exists that the F-35 deal won't fit with historical cost trends. "This means that it is possible that the F-35 constitutes an outlier, in that its costs might be significantly different relative to what the historical trend would suggest," the report states.
The fighter jet program has already been plagued by delays and cost overruns during the development phase of the aircraft. Page's report says that if those problems translate into a higher purchase cost, "overall production volume may be threatened."
Liberal industry critic Marc Garneau has argued that the government has refused to be honest with Canadians about the procurement deal and all its costs, and that money likely would be saved if an open competition were held.
"What they are telling us is that we're going to buy aircraft, but we're not going to tell you how much they cost," said Garneau on Wednesday.
"They refuse to issue a tender to ensure the Canadian Air Force is getting the best aircraft at the best price."
With files from The Canadian Press
No comments:
Post a Comment